Discussion Forum
Hopefully everything will work smoothly for you – however, if there is something wrong, please take a moment to email us (forum@badminton-coach.co.uk) so that we can put it right !
Please do not SPAM this forum – anyone found posting non-badminton related messages or ADVERTISING without permission will be removed without notice and may be banned from using the forum in the future.
Membership of this Badminton Discussion Forum is FREE
To join, just click the Register button just BELOW on the right. Please note however that any strange email addresses (lots of random letters etc) with an obscure user name will be deleted.
2:11 pm
May 25, 2010
I thought I'd start a new topic, although this is relevant to two other topics (shoes and setting an example of the younger generation).
I recently played the final match of the season and also in a tournament.
In the match, due to the fact that our club had to play another match at home at the same time as ours, we only had two courts for two hours instead of three courts for two hours (it's a four court hall). It's do-able to get the games done in time, but the opposition seemed to time waste to try an push for some games to be forfeited. Has anyone here experienced such things? And I know it depends on which league you play in (as each league can alter the rules slightly as the BE rules are there for just as a guideline), but how much time is allowed between ends?
One bloke finished an end, got a top of a flask (cup of tea maybe??), walked all the way over to the other side of the hall to talk to his partner who was waiting for him (to play the next end), had a (long) chat. Then walked all the way back, messed about a bit with a towel then FINALLY got back on court! Never seen anything like it!
And he wasn't the only one in their team. We were stood around for AGES between ends. I thought you only allow a few minutes.
On to the tournament, and I have now experienced what it's like to play against a pair that use a towel for their shoes in between points A LOT. There aren't that many players in our league that do this but this pair were doing it after every single point played. At one point a player went off, danced on the towel (I now call it a dancing mat!), his partner followed suit, they were just about to serve then the player went back to the towel for another little dance!! Obviously they didn't dance, and they just stamped on the towel or whatever, but it sure looks like dancing to me!
I'm sorry, I know some of you have issues with Yonex shoes, but it really isn't my fault that you don't buy adequate footwear! It's turning into tennis and the players getting a towel after every point in that drives me bonkers. To do it every now and then is about bare-able, but every point is a complete waste of time. You don't see the professionals do it so you can not say that they are setting a bad example.
Rant over!
I will agree, that as I don't suffer from the problem, I have a different perception. This is why I would like to know other peoples opinions (and stories of their own). But I just feel that if I was to turn up and play badminton in flip flops and after every point having to stop and mess about with them, then the opposition would get annoyed and say that it's not their fault that I am not wearing the correct shoes. I'm not saying that you need different shoes for different halls, but there are some shoe ranges that are not fit for any surface type except professional courts. Yonex should advertise this bit! Unless this is a cunning plan by Yonex, to sell more Yonex towels!
I'd like to hear other people's stories of players time wasting, I'm sure there must be some players out there that push this to the limit!
Badminton Gives Me A Purpose In Life – To Serve Others
I'd Rather Be Playing Badminton…………..
6:59 pm
March 10, 2013
Your right to highlight the time wasting Pete.
So called “gamesmanship” happens in all sports. Footballers “winning” a penalty, cricketers verbal antics and ball tampering etc etc.
Cheats are cowards and bullies and will only abuse the laws of the game if they think they can get away with it.
From my experience most players are decent ,honest and reasonable and, rather than confront the cheaters, would rather not make a fuss. Unfortunately this perpetuates the cheating.
Personally I find nothing wrong in quoting the rules to players who abuse them and I always carry an up to date copy in my bag. After all, their going to find it difficult to argue if you show it to them in black and white.
Here is a section of the laws that deal with some of Pete's issues.
16.1 Play shall be continuous from the first service until the match is concluded, except as allowed in
Laws 16.2 and 16.3,
16.2 Intervals:
16.2.1 not exceeding 60 seconds during each game when the leading score reaches 11 points;
and
16.2.2 not exceeding 120 seconds between the first and second game, and between the second
and third game shall be allowed in all matches.
I appreciate that the 60 sec break in a game is little used in club matches, but the laws can apply to all levels.
Time wasting between the matches is a bit more problematic particularly if opponents or indeed yourselves have just come off court and are expected to go straight back on. I would say that a 5 min breather would be acceptable and should be agreed by the players as soon as they conclude their match.
The important point is to stand up for what is right and not let the cheats ride roughshod over you.
1:25 pm
VIP Coaching Program Members
August 12, 2010
Peter Warman said:
I thought I'd start a new topic, although this is relevant to two other topics (shoes and setting an example of the younger generation).
I recently played the final match of the season and also in a tournament.
In the match, due to the fact that our club had to play another match at home at the same time as ours, we only had two courts for two hours instead of three courts for two hours (it's a four court hall). It's do-able to get the games done in time, but the opposition seemed to time waste to try an push for some games to be forfeited. Has anyone here experienced such things? And I know it depends on which league you play in (as each league can alter the rules slightly as the BE rules are there for just as a guideline), but how much time is allowed between ends?
One bloke finished an end, got a top of a flask (cup of tea maybe??), walked all the way over to the other side of the hall to talk to his partner who was waiting for him (to play the next end), had a (long) chat. Then walked all the way back, messed about a bit with a towel then FINALLY got back on court! Never seen anything like it!
And he wasn't the only one in their team. We were stood around for AGES between ends. I thought you only allow a few minutes.
On to the tournament, and I have now experienced what it's like to play against a pair that use a towel for their shoes in between points A LOT. There aren't that many players in our league that do this but this pair were doing it after every single point played. At one point a player went off, danced on the towel (I now call it a dancing mat!), his partner followed suit, they were just about to serve then the player went back to the towel for another little dance!! Obviously they didn't dance, and they just stamped on the towel or whatever, but it sure looks like dancing to me!
I'm sorry, I know some of you have issues with Yonex shoes, but it really isn't my fault that you don't buy adequate footwear! It's turning into tennis and the players getting a towel after every point in that drives me bonkers. To do it every now and then is about bare-able, but every point is a complete waste of time. You don't see the professionals do it so you can not say that they are setting a bad example.
Rant over!
I will agree, that as I don't suffer from the problem, I have a different perception. This is why I would like to know other peoples opinions (and stories of their own). But I just feel that if I was to turn up and play badminton in flip flops and after every point having to stop and mess about with them, then the opposition would get annoyed and say that it's not their fault that I am not wearing the correct shoes. I'm not saying that you need different shoes for different halls, but there are some shoe ranges that are not fit for any surface type except professional courts. Yonex should advertise this bit! Unless this is a cunning plan by Yonex, to sell more Yonex towels!
I'd like to hear other people's stories of players time wasting, I'm sure there must be some players out there that push this to the limit!
Peter, I am going to have to call you on this one. Taking excessive time between games – unnaceptaable. Completely agree. However, using towel on shoes, I will never agree with you. The reasons are twofold:
– When a floor is dusty, it is NOT fit for badminton. It is dangerous. It is not generally dangerous for players who do not move much. However, for myself, I know that playing in a dusty hall IS dangerous. I do not hold back when I move, and if I am going to slide a foot before I stop, then I am going to hurt myself. Similarly, when pushing off, I am going to pull something because the floor is dangerous. I will never criticise an opponent for wiping their shoes between points, if the floor is dirty. Whilst you can argue about time limits between points, and breaking rules, the bottom line is the court is dangerous and anything a player does to mitigate that danger is fine in my book.
– You can never know how easily an opponent is moving, how they feel, or how safe they feel. They have the right to feel safe on court, and be assured that they are doing everything they can to make sure that they do not suffer an injury. I do not think it is my right to tell them what they can or can't do with respect to their own personal safety. Your analogy about flip flops is not applicable – you have chosen to wear a non badminton related shoe. Anyone with proper badminton shoes (even if they are a brand you don't like) should not be forced to play in an unsafe way, just because you do not have the courtesy to wait. This isn't mind games, this is just common courtesy and good manners.
End of my rant. Sorry to call you up on this Pete, but in this case, I think you are wrong!
2:18 pm
May 25, 2010
Hi Matt!
I was expecting someone to respond like that!
As I said, it doesn't effect me so I'm looking from a different perspective. Also, I did say that I didn't mind a mild use of the towel but when it becomes excessive then where do you draw the line?
I do understand what you are saying about player safety and I do agree. The last thing I'd want is someone to injure themselves. This is the problem where something gets allowed and them some people push the rules to the limit turning it into a negative effect. Whilst I mention Yonex, I'm sure there are other shoes that may have the same problem, but I have only seen Yonex shoe wearers suffer from this. That is either because Yonex are at fault or because there are more Yonex shoes being worn and therefore more noticeable?
And it's a difficult subject as we all play in different types of halls. The hall that I played in had a new floor not so long ago and didn't seem particularly dusty to me. But where do you draw the line. As you say, if a player feels unsafe then they should be allowed to do something to make them safe. But as you can't monitor how safe a player feels, this means they can manipulate it.
Say for example, I had to straighten my strings out after EVERY point and it taking me awhile because I don't feel like they are ready for use. Is that fair? Would the empire not tell me to get on with it?
I think we should role reverse Matt. You need to play in the most non-dusty hall you can find and ask your opponents to use the towel after every point and drag the game out. I know it may sound like I'm being impatient in between each point but I don't mind waiting a bit, but there's a limit.
And maybe I need to use a towel myself after every point using the most dusty hall that I can find and see the difference myself.
I know there are always players that will do this (bent the rules, poor gamesmanship etc), but I'm just raising the topic for discussion
Badminton Gives Me A Purpose In Life – To Serve Others
I'd Rather Be Playing Badminton…………..
8:17 am
VIP Coaching Program Members
December 4, 2010
I played in a match this season just gone where as soon as they went a few points down, they did the shoe lace untie / tie up etc. They would apologise,( my partner & I were getting vexed by this) I said don’t worry I could do with a rest as got a stitch & feel knackered. Funnily enough there time wasting stopped & we duly beat then. Think if the umpires in the professional tournaments jumped on this straight away 1 warning then a yellow card, then red etc.
If I was warming up & felt the floor was dusty, I would ask them to sweep the court, & I take a wet rag with me & put by the net post (& at an appropriate time wipe the soles of the shoes) as this helps to improve your shoes grip.
Maybe when the score cards are returned there should be a space to mark your opponents conduct good or bad. Then as well as results there could be a league table showing up the cheats.
7:32 pm
February 15, 2011
I agree with the comments raised so far. Sadly, some of the behaviour of players is appalling. I blame the umpires, tournament referees, national associations supporting the players and coaches. First off, the umpires should make the call early and set the scene for the tournament.
The tournament referees should have a word with all coaches or national body representatives to advise there is a zero tolerance for this kind of behaviour and umpires are advised to stamp it out.
I also feel national associations should warn their players that this behaviour is unacceptable and any signs on court will be dealt with in a disciplinary manner.
Coaches have their part to play. Any signs in a training session and they should warn players their place is in jeopardy if they continue.
We've had a rule for a long time that play must be continuous. I don't mind an odd towelling down but constant chatter amongst players, tying shoe laces, not being ready for the serve is NOT on.
Anybody representing a club, league of body in an official capacity must lead by example. As for the rest of us, let's ensure we show everybody how it's done and play the game fairly. I'd rather lose fair and square than cheat my way to success.
Paul
7:59 pm
December 10, 2011
Fortunately I've never played in a match with the opponents blatantly time-wasting but I agree that it needs to be stamped on. With regard to players walking onto a damp towel between points, this I fully understand as I've had to do this myself at several venues where the floor was slippery and basically unfit for play. If I decide to play in the league next season it will be on the captain's understanding that a reserve will stand in for me at said places.
It occurs to me that if games were to 7 or 11 over five sets there would be less excuse for towelling down between points. Perhaps one 30 second break could be allowed per game.
12:24 pm
February 15, 2011
Dee
I agree with the damp towel situation, however it's a shame that floors are so poor in some leisure centres that this is required.
My local leisure centre floor is appalling. Despite my complaints, nothing is done. The leisure centre manager tells me that they have had the floor tested by the manufacturer and they consider it passes. I'm sorry but any independent sports person will rip this report to pieces on the grounds that the floor is dangerous. Overall, I cannot coach at this venue now because the floor is simply too slippery for any decent footwork. I only use it for specific skills work when we're not focussing on feet and only hand skills.
Paul
7:34 pm
December 31, 2011
Paul Stewart said:
Dee
I agree with the damp towel situation, however it's a shame that floors are so poor in some leisure centres that this is required.
My local leisure centre floor is appalling. Despite my complaints, nothing is done. The leisure centre manager tells me that they have had the floor tested by the manufacturer and they consider it passes. I'm sorry but any independent sports person will rip this report to pieces on the grounds that the floor is dangerous. Overall, I cannot coach at this venue now because the floor is simply too slippery for any decent footwork. I only use it for specific skills work when we're not focussing on feet and only hand skills.
Paul
Paul,
Slightly off topic but I have to agree with your comments – we have a centre that has the same problem – they keep promising to reseal the floor/strip and re-varnish etc etc yet nothing happens! Coaching on it or playing is at best difficult and, at worst, just downright dangerous.
John
Most Users Ever Online: 676
Currently Online:
11 Guest(s)
Currently Browsing this Page:
1 Guest(s)
Top Posters:
Matthew Seeley: 391
Peter Warman: 239
Ed: 186
Dobbie98: 165
gingerphil79: 158
Member Stats:
Guest Posters: 10
Members: 1532
Moderators: 1
Admins: 2
Forum Stats:
Groups: 2
Forums: 8
Topics: 581
Posts: 4716
Newest Members:
vishu08, t123, LucaSchlietz, ehsianturi, wkt_1Moderators: Design: 0
Administrators: AngieS: 0, Paul Stewart: 1283