Discussion Forum
Hopefully everything will work smoothly for you – however, if there is something wrong, please take a moment to email us (forum@badminton-coach.co.uk) so that we can put it right !
Please do not SPAM this forum – anyone found posting non-badminton related messages or ADVERTISING without permission will be removed without notice and may be banned from using the forum in the future.
Membership of this Badminton Discussion Forum is FREE
To join, just click the Register button just BELOW on the right. Please note however that any strange email addresses (lots of random letters etc) with an obscure user name will be deleted.
10:11 pm
March 2, 2010
When I started, I was rather convinced the racket you used didn't make all that difference. But of course my experience was limited to 1 single racket. A fairly good Yonex MP33. When I needed a new one, I came across that famous Yonex diagram and found it was time for something different. So I tried a head heavy AT, and wow what was that ! Luckily I didn't go for the 700 for the step from the 33 would have been too much. But this choice really took my shots to another level.
So my initial thought the racket doesn't matter, I've put aside. But since I cannot imagine Yonex is producing rackets for fun, here's my question: once you reach the level your hits are consistent, and you want to invest in equipment, what would you chose ? Do you go for head heavy, or high tension, or both ? Do you prefer repulsion ? What kind of player would you as a trainer advice to go for ? What do you look at for chosing or advising a specific kind of racket ? I mean, why does TH play with AS ? Why does LCW use AT (according the Yonex diagram, the other side of the spectrum) ?
What about the handgrip ? Do you thicken it with extra tape ? Some told me if you close your hand arround the grip and you touch with your fingertips your handpalm, you need an extra thick grip. I think if you ask 10 players this question, you get 10 different answers.
So, badminton world out there, share your experience.
11:22 pm
VIP Coaching Program Members
August 12, 2010
What a fantastic and yet simple question… what makes a racket feel “right”? Or perhaps which one is “best”? The only comment I am willing to make, is that when you pick up a racket consider this:
- If the racket feels like it is just right when you hold it in your hand, you MAY have found your favourite racket – it may feel like an extension to your arm!
- When you swing that racket and it just seems to come through at the right pace, your different varieties of shots are all enhanced by this racket, or changed in a way that feels good, then you MAY have found your favourite racket.
- When you put on a grip that feels good in your hand and doesn't hinder your shotmaking, you MAY have found your favourite grip – remembering that the way you grip may change the “balance point” of the racket, potentially making a heavy racket feel lighter than it is when you swing it.
- When you put in strings at a various tension and you like the pace of the shots produced, or the sound it makes, or the feel on impact, then you MAY have found your favourite tension
- When you try out different strings in your racket, and one string just makes your shots feel so much more ALIVE! Then you MAY have found your favourite string
Keep these things in mind. Personally, the second bullet point is the most important for me. This means when I hit a drive or a smash or anything else, it just feels like I have complete control over WHERE the racket will start and finish and it just does what I want it to do.
I cannot give you a definitive answer, but I believe most players, including professionals, choose a racket that just feels right for WHAT THEY WANT. Some big smashers, who can smash big with any racket, MAY choose a racket that is head heavy to give them a more powerful smash, or they MAY choose a lighter racket that will enhance their defensive skills – perhaps an area they struggle with typically! Why is it that Lee Chong Wei, known for his amazing defense, uses what is considered to be an extremely powerful racket. Does it help him be a more complete player by increasing his offensive skills, or does it just feel right for all of his shots anyway? I don't know the answers I am afraid.
For me:
I want the racket to come through at the right pace and give me a good feeling throughout the shot. I then practise lots and it becomes an extension of my arm if it wasn't before. At this point, I consider grips and strings! I tend to choose overgrips but wrapped around the handle multiple times, making them a bit thicker. The reason? I found the feel of the grip becomes nicer over time, whereas others tend to get “worn out”. My own personal preference. I experimented a bit with tensions, found one I liked with a string that makes my shots FEEL good, and there we have it.
So, what was my point? Does the racket make a difference in terms of your game? Probably not. Does it make a difference in terms of the way it makes you feel? YES! And this affects your game, because you now have a new fantastic happy mindset! Hooray!
You asked “what do you go for”? Is it head heavy? High tension? Personally I like balanced rackets. I learnt with a balanced racket, and have always liked them! Head heavy or head light just feels wrong in my hand. I prefer a tension of around 24 – 25lbs. This is quite high. I know some people who would swear by a higher tension though. I would recommend reading Pauls article on string tensions for more details. The only other attribute I REALLY consider, is the shaft flexibility. I learnt with a stiff shafted racket, and I have never got on with flexible ones quite the way I do stiff ones. Im sure if I practised I would like them, but actually the stiffer it is the better it feels to me, as I FEEL i get more control.
If you give a professional any racket, they will still be amazing. To a certain degree it doesn't make a difference, but if you can find one that feels right… then thats the right one 🙂
This is my opinon. Sorry for the rant.
Matt
1:50 pm
April 4, 2010
I will just add one little thing to what Matthew has said which I totally agree with.
Be sure your grip is thick enough for your hand because it may cause tendonitis if it is too thin. Ok, it is not the only reason but that may contribute especially if you're using a head-heavy racket without having an arm strong enough. It happened to me but now I'm quite OK.
My AR-600 is a head-heavy racket with the balance in the head (normal) now it is in the middle due to the fact I add surgrips on it… That doesn't disturb me when playing. On my racket grip, I have the original Yonex grip and I add myself two very thin surgrips (0,55mm layer) and I'm just doing fine. So don't be afraid if your racket balance will change.
2:08 pm
VIP Coaching Program Members
August 12, 2010
I couldn't agree with jonathan more! Changing the weight slightly should not be a concern most of the time. However, where too thin a grip may give you physical problems, too chick a grip may hinder your shot making by stopping you from effectively using finger tightening! If it feels comfortable, its probably the right one 😀
8:36 am
March 2, 2010
This is the very first time I read about grip thickness and tendonitis in one sentence. So very good tip, thanks ! But how do you know your grip is too thin ? Is there some rule of thumb (very handy in this context) that defines this ?
Second question: if somebody asks what racket you would recomend him, I would say “play a match and I'll watch”. So when you see somebody play, are there any objective criteria you can use to link a type of player to a type/brand of racket ? Type of string ? Type of grip ? Supose you see somebody play, and is playing very good. You see the type of racket and you think, if this person would play with this kind of racket, he/she would blow the opponent of the court. Let the replies come.
10:05 am
VIP Coaching Program Members
August 12, 2010
Ed, unfortunately there is no measure of grip thickness to help us out! If the grip is resembling a tennis handle grip in size, its probably too big to allow effective use of finger power, but not necessarily. Remember all people are different, and some have small hands and some big. I would say that the grip in your hand should feel like it is filling a lot of your grip (note this is when you have a relaxed grip!!!), you don't have to grip too tight to hold on to it, but that also there is SOME space within the grip. It could be “a lot” and it could be “some”. What I have just said is extremely vague. With good technique and getting used to your type of grip, you should be fine 🙂
As to your second question. No. There are no criteria from watching them play that will allow you to make a truly good recommendation, but here are some thoughts:
If they like to play smashes a lot, they may enjoy a head heavy racket to enhance their game OR a head light racket may give them more power due to racket head speed. What do they use at the moment? They will PROBABLY like a racket similar to their current one probably!
Defensive players typically use a head light racket.
In general a very interesting property of the racket: stiffness, is an area it MAY be possible to advise someone on. Have a look at the “length” of their overhead action. If the length appears to be small and compact, with minimal movement (same goes for defensive shots/drives with minimal movement) it is MAYBE the case that a stiffer racket will FEEL better to that player. A “longer” looking shot with a larger wind up, will PERHAPS mean that the player prefers a flexible racket. Generally a beginner will typically feel more benefits in terms of power generation from a flexible racket for this reason.
For a reasonable explanation of this read this link:
http://www.badmintoncentral.co…..-explained
I believe it makes some valid observations.
Finally, is it possible to recommend strings/tensions/grips from watching somebody play. No. Because this is even MORE personal than trying to find the right racket.
In general, I would suggest a racket that is similar to the one they are currently playing with, but that I believe offers a little bit “more” of what they like. I would never recommend buying without testing however! And that is the most important bit. If they test it, they will KNOW whether they like it or not.
12:09 am
February 15, 2011
This is a big topic with many parts so I thought about this a lot before giving my thoughts.
I get asked about racquets and “what's best for a player” type question virtually every day. My answer is always the same i.e. test and make your own choice. Essentially the racquet should feel like an extension of your arm. But…
Tensions – I do have some recommendations based on 25 years string and coaching experience. I've strung for European Champions to All England finalists to beginners.
My rule of thumb is to begin with certain tensions and then increase in 1lb increments until you find the tension for you.
Plastic shuttles – max 19lbs
feather shuttles + plastic shuttles – max 21lbs
feather shuttles – begin at 20lbs
Grip size, again this may be personal choice as mentioned previously, but if the third finger is overlapping the fleshy part of your thumb, the grip is too small. This results in excessive gripping which can lead to tennis elbow or other elbow injuries.
If the third finger is just touching the fleshy part of the thumb, then this is a starting point. After that, test. In his early years Peter Gade used a smaller grip and I think he hit harder than he does now. But, his grip is a lot wider now and i believe he has decided to sacrifice some power for greater accuracy/control which he must feel he's getting from his racquet. That's a personal thing and certainly doesn't mean we should all do the same.
I'm constantly dabbling in grips and still don't feel I've found my ultimate grip size. That said, I'm not playing very much so feeding shuttles is less demanding that playing.
Recommending racquets is something I'm asked about all the time as I said earlier. Here's my thoughts…
A player with natural power can choose between head light, head heavy or balanced racquet.
A player without natural power may suffer from a head light racquet. Initially they may find they get more power because of the weight differential from their heavier racquet. This will eventually diminish.
This type of player needs to consider whether a head heavy racquet will give them more power. They also need to consider flexibilty in shaft and whether they need that extra kick to assist them in the power stakes.
As Matthew said, if the player has a big wind up, then they are more likely to need help in terms of flexibility of shaft. Whether they go to a head heavy racquet will depend on their style of play. A defender type player isn't interested in head heavy racquets, they're looking for speed to counter-hit from defence and around the net. An aggressive attacker of thinking attacker may look more towards the heavy head to give them that extra ooomph in their attack.
So, it is tough to recommend for another player. I always go through a questioning process to reduce the number of possibilities and what remains becomes the starting point. After all this, if they don't like initial suggestions, then at least they're giving me more data to close in on their ideal racquet.
Good topic
Paul
9:47 am
October 25, 2010
Personally one thing I have learnt over the last year, and had strongly confirmed by Paul, is string tension (in my opinion) can be more important than racket choice. All too often I see players who are able to play with any racket, there will be slight increases going from racket to racket, or indeed drops in power/control etc. But if you give them a racket with a tension higher than they're able to cope with, it'll have huge effects on thier game.
Obviously a player's racket is very important, but I often urge new players not to worry too much about thier racket choice initially, and to think more about finding a tension that suits thier game.
There are a few members at each of my clubs, who seem to have a new racket each week, and at times I think they simply benefit from the confidence or “buzz” that stems from having a new racket, which normally lasts for the first couple of times they use it.
Its sometimes better to try different tensions before buying loads of different rackets, if only for the fact having a racket restrung a couple of times, is a lot cheaper than buying multiple rackets.
7:44 am
March 2, 2010
Very nice tips. This grip thickness is bothering me for a while now, so I'm glad I finally have some directions now.
I usually don't give advice, but you cannot always deny the question and send them walking. But when I do give advice, I tell them to be conservative in buying rackets (it's still a hobby), be aware of high string tensions (thanks Paul), don't search for limits (like when you're used to play with head light, don't swap with the heaviest head heavy racket). And now I can add the grip thickness tip.
Thanks a lot all for contributing. If anybody has something to add to this, don't hesitate to do so !
Cheers, ED
Most Users Ever Online: 676
Currently Online:
127 Guest(s)
Currently Browsing this Page:
1 Guest(s)
Top Posters:
Matthew Seeley: 391
Peter Warman: 239
Ed: 186
Dobbie98: 165
gingerphil79: 158
Member Stats:
Guest Posters: 10
Members: 1529
Moderators: 1
Admins: 2
Forum Stats:
Groups: 2
Forums: 8
Topics: 581
Posts: 4716
Newest Members:
ehsianturi, wkt_1, merlyn, Suzena, ManojModerators: Design: 0
Administrators: AngieS: 0, Paul Stewart: 1283